An AgencyAnalytics alternative for agencies that only report on search
Last updated: 2026-11-17
AgencyAnalytics is a client reporting platform for marketing agencies with 90+ integrations, a white-labeled client portal, scheduled reports and MCP access, at $20 per client per month billed annually. GSC Magic is not a dashboard builder. It connects Claude, ChatGPT and other AI clients to Search Console, Bing Webmaster Tools and GA4, with an Agency plan at $35 a month for 25 sites. Multi-channel agencies should stay with AgencyAnalytics; SEO-only freelancers and small agencies may be paying for channels they never use.
The short answer
AgencyAnalytics describes itself as client intelligence for marketing agencies. It pulls data from 90+ marketing platforms, from Search Console, Google Analytics and Bing Webmaster Tools to ad, social, email and call tracking tools, into dashboards and reports. Clients get a white-labeled portal with your logo, colors and custom domain, and reports go out on a schedule by e-mail, PDF or link. Its AI features include Ask AI, AI Summary and an AgencyAI report builder, and an MCP connection lets admins and staff query client data from Claude, ChatGPT and other AI tools. The Core plan costs $20 per client per month, billed annually.
GSC Magic covers a much smaller slice: search data only. It has no white-label branding, no client portal on your own domain and no ad or social integrations. What it offers is depth on search inside your AI assistant: URL Inspection in batches, sitemaps, Core Web Vitals, Bing keyword research and ready-made reports such as quick wins and traffic drops, plus a monthly e-mail report per client on the Agency plan. If your agency sells SEO and little else, that may be enough at a flat price.
Side by side
| Feature | AgencyAnalytics | GSC Magic |
|---|---|---|
| Main job | Multi-channel client reporting: dashboards, scheduled reports and a white-labeled client portal | Answering questions about search data in AI clients, plus a web dashboard; not a report builder |
| Price | Core plan: $20 per client per month, billed annually; the pricing page does not show a monthly-billing price; volume pricing for 25+ clients | Free plan for 1 site; Pro $19/month for 10 sites; Agency $35/month for 25 sites |
| Trial | 14-day free trial, no credit card; 30-day money-back guarantee | Permanent free plan for 1 site; 7-day Pro trial, no card |
| Data sources | 90+ integrations, including Search Console, Google Analytics, Bing Webmaster Tools, PPC, social, email, local and call tracking | Search Console, Bing Webmaster Tools (38 tools), GA4 (read-only) and Core Web Vitals; no ad, social or email platforms |
| Users and client access | Unlimited staff users and client users; white-labeled client portal with your logo, colors and custom domain | Agency: 5 seats with owner, admin, member and viewer roles and client groups; no white-label branding |
| Client reports | Scheduled reports by e-mail, PDF or shareable link; approval before sending on select plans | Agency: monthly report per client group by e-mail with month-over-month change, top queries and pages and AI-assistant traffic |
| AI and MCP | Ask AI, AI Summary, AgencyAI report builder (open beta); MCP for Claude, ChatGPT and other AI tools, for admins and staff users, up to 10 named clients per prompt | Hosted MCP server for Claude, ChatGPT, Claude Code, Cursor, VS Code, Windsurf and other MCP clients; Ask AI chat in the dashboard on Pro and Agency |
| Search diagnostics | Search Console queries, pages, sitemaps and crawl errors; Bing queries, pages and crawl errors | URL Inspection single and batch, sitemaps, Bing keyword research, Core Web Vitals and 8 SEO reports such as quick wins, traffic drops and cannibalization |
| Rank and AI visibility tracking | Add-ons billed annually: Rank Tracker $41.67/month per 500 keywords, AI Tracker $20.83/month per 250 credits | No rank tracker; average position comes from Search Console and Bing |
| Changes made by the AI | MCP can add clients and users and edit custom metrics and views inside AgencyAnalytics | Optional on Pro and Agency: submit sitemaps, IndexNow and Bing URL submission |
Keep using it if
- You report on more than search: ads, social, email, e-commerce or call tracking in one client report.
- Clients expect their own logins to a white-labeled portal with your logo, colors and custom domain.
- You send branded scheduled reports as PDFs or links and want an approval step before they go out.
- You manage more than 25 clients or need unlimited staff and client users.
- You use its Rank Tracker or AI Tracker add-ons.
GSC Magic fits better if
- Your agency sells SEO only and most of the 90+ integrations sit unused.
- You pay per client for a handful of sites: 10 clients on AgencyAnalytics cost $200 a month billed annually, while GSC Magic Agency is $35 a month for up to 25 sites.
- You want search diagnostics in the AI chat: batch URL Inspection, sitemaps, Core Web Vitals and reports such as quick wins and traffic drops.
- You work in Cursor, Claude Code, VS Code or Windsurf as well as Claude and ChatGPT.
- A plain monthly e-mail report per client is enough and clients do not need a branded portal.
Using them together
Yes, if you want both. An agency can keep AgencyAnalytics for the branded multi-channel reports clients see, and use GSC Magic for the search work behind those reports: why a page lost clicks, which URLs are not indexed, how Bing compares with Google. Both read Search Console through Google's own access, so connecting one does not affect the other, and Claude allows several connectors in the same conversation. A common pattern is to spot a dip in the client report, then ask your AI assistant with GSC Magic to find the pages and queries behind it.
Questions
Does GSC Magic offer white-label reports or a client portal?
No. GSC Magic has no white-label branding, custom domain or client portal. On the Agency plan you can invite clients as viewers within your 5 seats and send a monthly e-mail report per client group. If branded client access is part of what you sell, keep AgencyAnalytics.
Does AgencyAnalytics have an MCP server?
Yes. Its help center documents MCP access for Claude, ChatGPT and other AI tools. Only admins and staff users can connect, a prompt can cover up to 10 named clients, and the rate limit is 100 requests per minute. It reads the integrations you connected, including Search Console, Google Analytics and Bing Webmaster Tools.
What does AgencyAnalytics cost for 10 clients?
Based on its pricing page, $20 per client per month billed annually, so $200 a month or $2,400 a year for 10 clients. The page does not show a monthly-billing price. GSC Magic Pro covers 10 sites for $19 a month, and Agency covers 25 sites with 5 seats for $35 a month. The two products do different jobs, so compare what you will actually use.
Can GSC Magic replace AgencyAnalytics for a full-service agency?
No. GSC Magic reads Search Console, Bing Webmaster Tools, GA4 and Core Web Vitals only. It has no ad, social, email or call tracking data, no dashboard builder and no rank tracker. It fits agencies and freelancers whose client work is search.
Sources
Facts checked on 2026-11-17
- agencyanalytics.com https://agencyanalytics.com/pricing
- agencyanalytics.com https://agencyanalytics.com/
- agencyanalytics.com https://agencyanalytics.com/integrations
- agencyanalytics.com https://agencyanalytics.com/integrations/google-search-console
- agencyanalytics.com https://agencyanalytics.com/integrations/google-analytics
- agencyanalytics.com https://agencyanalytics.com/integrations/bing-webmaster-tools
- agencyanalytics.com https://agencyanalytics.com/features/white-label
- agencyanalytics.com https://agencyanalytics.com/feature/report-scheduling
- agencyanalytics.com https://agencyanalytics.com/features/ai-reporting-tools
- agencyanalytics.com https://agencyanalytics.com/features/model-context-protocol
- help.agencyanalytics.com https://help.agencyanalytics.com/en/articles/14791103-model-context-protocol-mcp